In response to: A Reader's New Year Challenge: You should brush up your history lessons, Mr. School Of Vice
To Khmerization...
As I have said before, the issue of the island is not debatable, it belongs to Vietnam, and Vietnam reserves the right to station whatever it wants on the island, it does not have to ask anyone’s consent. I am certain Vietnam is not alone in this action. As for the disputed territories, Vietnam is working with friends and partners to resolve the complex issues to the satisfactory of all parties involved.
As I have said before, the issue of the island is not debatable, it belongs to Vietnam, and Vietnam reserves the right to station whatever it wants on the island, it does not have to ask anyone’s consent. I am certain Vietnam is not alone in this action. As for the disputed territories, Vietnam is working with friends and partners to resolve the complex issues to the satisfactory of all parties involved.
In regard to the history of Champa and Khmer Krom, it is what it is- history. Constantly ranting about it is silly. It is not wise to dig up past historical grievances in order to justify one’s hostility against other people, it is unacceptable among the community of civilized nations. Even Cambodia’s history has shown that the Khmers were not the innocent victims of foreign conquests and subjugation as they would like to portray themselves to be. They were party to the act of military conquests, they vied for power, land, and resources, and at one time, they were the subjugators. Cambodians are very proud of their so-called Khmer Empire. How else was that empire carved but from the pointed end of the swords. In fact, Angkor Wat and many of its ancient temples were built by slaves from lands that it had subjugated. Champa was among the victims of Khmer military adventurism. Had the Khmer won, they would not be the one crying foul, they would be the victor and subjugator. Cambodia is simply the end result of failed military recklessness against its neighbors. No respectable international scholars and historians will give you the time of day to listen to your highly subjective, distorted, and falsify history.
It is not hard to understand the current political situation of Cambodia
or any other country, if you look at it from a realistic and pragmatic
viewpoint, something, it seems to me, many Cambodians lack. It is that
lack of pragmatism that has caused Cambodia dearly. The truth is
Vietnam is not encroaching upon Cambodia, it is not trying to subjugate
Cambodia, and it is not plotting to turn Cambodia into Vietnam or
Cambodians in Vietnamese. Those are false and groundless accusations leveled by overseas Cambodians and a few insignificant opposition
members in order to advance their agenda because they play very little
to no relevancy in Cambodia’s political affair. Like all country,
Vietnam is pursuing its interests, and it is in Vietnam’s interests to
maintain a pro-Vietnam government in Cambodia, a government that is
friendly to Vietnam, the same goes with Laos. There is historical
reason for it. While the world watched and did absolutely nothing as
the Khmer Rouge was destroying Cambodia, and launched unprovoked brutal attacks into Vietnam, in respsonse to the incursions, Vietnam along
with the current leaders of Cambodia toppled the genocidal Khmer rouge,
liberated the country, saved millions of people, and brought about the
revival of Cambodia as we see it today. It is the most profound and true humanitarian act that the people of one country could do for the
people of another. From that historical context, it is not hard to
understand why the CPP is the current ruling government of Cambodia.
Every militarily capable country maintains and defends the strategic
space adjacent to it. The US does not allow any foreign power to use
Mexico to threaten it security, likewise, Vietnam would never allow any
foreign power to use Cambodia to threaten its security. Both Cambodia
and Laos are sovereign states, and could pursue independent foreign
policies, so long as their policies do not threaten their neighbors.
The oppositions and overseas Cambodians harbored hostile and malicious
intentions towards Vietnam, and given the chance, they will commit acts
of violence against innocent Vietnamese and their own countrymen they
deemed working with Vietnam. Those are the same people who recently
called for a Libya-style destruction of Cambodia because they harbored
the delusion that it would help propel them to power in Cambodia.
However, Cambodia will never again walk the path of self-destruction.
As Hun Sen made it clear, he would continue to rule Cambodia into his
90s, after him, members of the CPP will rule Cambodia. Vietnam will
make certain that is as true as the rising and setting of the sun.
17 comments:
You made points correctly but you FAILED to mention that it was Vietnam that created Khmer Isarak and later changed into Khmer Viet Minhwho in turn formed into Khmer Rough, only then when KR decided not to hand over Cambodia to Hanoi then Viets invaded Cambodia. They then claimed liberation, Viets indirectly stop Pol Pot murderous, I and countless Cambodian thanks those Vietnamese soldiers who paid the ultimate scarified. Now please stop your strangling on my poor Cambodia and gave us our Fully truly Independent. Don't forget the current government were also involved in mass killing before they defected to Hanoi.
This is a very honest analysis from the writer. So here are the issues that future Khmers will have to think about.
1) The Viets will always and always need a friendly Cambodian government. The King knows that. Hun Sen knows that. So both are trying to be friendly to Vietnam. Both are benefiting from this relationship.
2) The Viets will always and always try to eliminate the government of Cambodia that is against it. We have seen Lon Nol and Pol Pot. Both were eliminated because they try to go against Vietnam. Both were doomed by their own making.
With that thoughts, there is hope that there can be an alternative government for Cambodia if it is pro-Vietnam. CPP is only one. If we can show Vietnam that some other Party is not against them, I am sure they will let it compete with Hun Sen's government. After all, they don't care if the cat is black or white as long as it can catches mice. We must think about this. Why must opposition parties be anti-Vietnam? Our goal is to take back Cambodia from Hun Sen. That is the only way we have any chance to compete with Hun Sen. It's time we must think outside of the box.
I am not sure if the writer is a Vietnamese or a Khmer with Vietnamese head (kbal yuon, kluon Khmer), but he got history very wrong. He said Khmer Rouge attacked Vietnam unprovoked. The fact of the matter was that Viet soldiers encroached on Khmer border everyday like they are doing now and the KR soldiers tried to stop them, that's why the Viet launched a full scale war and invaded Cambodia.
The writer also said that Vietnam's invasion was "the most profound and true humanitarian act". The writer forgot that Vietnam was the one who created the KR, helped KR came to power in 1975 and then aided and abetted the KR in the killing of millions of Khmer life through Viet tricks. Vietnam did not come to save Khmer life, but invaded to annex more Khmer lands and kill more Khmer life like the K5 Plan. In fact, there are many claims and statistics pointing out that many more Khmers died or were killed after the Viet invasion in 1979.
The writer also accused overseas Khmers for inventing the story of Viet encroachments. No one will believe this claim because people can see with their own eyes that Vietnam are encroaching Khmer territory everyday and that Khmer farmers living along the border are crying everyday because Vietnamese soldiers had encroached on their lands. Does this writer think that these poor and unarmed Khmer farmers are the invaders of Vietnamese territory?
Regarding Champa and Kampuchea Krom, well, it is history but don't claim that they were Viet territory and the Chams and the Khmer Krom were invaders, right?
I believe that Cambodia and Vietnam should be friends, but do you think that friends won't invade or encroach on each other's land, right? I believe that we Khmers can't take back Kampuchea Krom, but we must never allow Vietnam to continue to encroach or chip away our territory on a daily basis. If you think that I have made up the story of Viet encroachments, then you just ask the farmers living along the border and they can tell you that they lost their land everyday.
History should be told the way it had happened, not twisted and turned.
We must be clear about the 7 jan 1979:
The KR while having political and territorial conflicts with Vietnam, killed their own people by all means.
Vietnam created the so called Salvation Front the 2 December 1979leaded by KR Heng Samrin, Chea Sin Hun Sen.....to be used as a facade to "come into" Cambodia, chased the KR and installed another Communist Regime leaded by Hun Sen Chea Sim......
The Real intention of Vietnam was not to save Cambodian people by to swallow Cambodia. If they care about Cambodian people why in 1982 Hun Sen Regime and Vietnam forced the survived Khmer people the the
K5 Strategic Plan which had killed many thousands of Hundred Cambodian, male and female.
Cambodian people are not stupid. They are not lurred by the 7 Jan 1979. They know the real Intention of Vietnam.
Shame on you all. If there is no benefit yuon won't invaded srok Khmer for free.Its an opportunity to conqer and putting spies to fulfil Ho chi Minh dreams for westward journey or indochona dream of ah Ho to get Khmer and Laos as its colonies forever.
Kmenhwatt
I just wonder about the race of the article writer. It is completely no national brain at all.
If Vietnam really wanted to help Cambodia and never wanted anything from Cambodia, why Vietnam tried very hard to save the 1980-1986 illegal treaties with the Cambodia People Party?
You said Khmer invade Cham. Vietnam took Kampuchea Krom from Cambodia. It is a nature? it is not reasonable at all.
We Cambodian never threaten any country, but what we have is the international law that all of the nations including the neighboring countries must respect.
We lost Koh Tral to Vietnam in 1979, now we need to file a complaint to the UN and ICJ to resolve this conflict. We have more favors in this case than Vietnam, why doesn't Cambodia to make a try?
Thailand, for example, even though ICJ already ruled that Preah Vihear temple belong to Cambodia according to the 1904-11906 maps, but they still make Cambodia go to the court again with them?
Even though they act very bad to us, they never betray their own country and they tries to many possible ways to get back what they lost.
How about Khmer? NOTHING besides living under other nation.
To 12:31 PM,
You are thinking in the box, to make it worse in the Vietnamese box.
January 7 is the day of infemy of the Viet invasion of Cambodia.
Hanoi used the pretence of " saving " Khmers from the Killing Fields.
The Killing Fields and the killings were the by-
products of Ho Chin Minh's Master Plan.
Since when, where, what and how, evil Yuon are nice, courteous, respectable, and helpful toward Khmers ?
Remember :
" Proa Jat Kom Pup Tae' Ong " !!!
Khmer Who Loves Khmers
5:10 PM,
To file a case with the UN and or the ICJ, there must be done by a government or at least sponsored by one.
Is Yuon puppet Hun Sen' s government going to do it ?
You already know the answer !!!
So Cambodia has no right of self-determination? Then it is not more like vietnams vasal. Good slave attitude school of vice. Protect your neck!
12:08 AM
What has this 'slave attitude' to do with School of Vice?!
I just think the Khmers inflicted pain and suffering to themselves. Khmers or Khmer politician should not blame others people for their own stupidity.
Without ho chi minh trails. There would not be communist Vietnam today. Who liberate them at that time during Vietnam war. Did they thanks us
No they don't. Instead they took koh tral island from us and borders encroachments then ask us to be their friend. How can they do these congioust. They rape us then walk with us to the world eyes with a smile. They really do think we are the ultimate fools.
Vietnam has studied in detail our weaknesses. One of them is fighting among Khmer brothers. Finally radical communist Hanoi wins. Don't be stupid most Asian countries politically and socially stuck in the 20 century.
Shame on you to the person that wrote these article. You don't shit about Khmer history or Khmer krom people
Post a Comment